Short answer: muddy skin is a value and temperature problem, not a colour problem. You chased the exact colour of a cheek before you sorted out your lights and shadows. Warm and cool then got stirred into grey. Chalky skin is the opposite mistake. You lightened with white instead of with warmth. Fix those two things, in that order, and the face comes right almost on its own.
You know the moment. You mix what looks like a convincing flesh tone on the palette. Then you lay it on the cheek, and the face turns to mud. Or it goes the other way and sits there like pink plaster. So you add a stroke to fix it. Then another. Each one makes it slightly worse. Soon the whole head is a flat brown smear with no light in it. I blamed the paint for years. It isn’t the paint.
The truth is that skin isn’t hard to mix. It only looks hard because we go at it in the wrong order. We reach for colour first. And colour is very nearly the last thing that matters.
The two ways skin goes wrong

It helps to know which problem you have, because the two fixes pull in opposite directions.
Mud is warm and cool paint stirred into a dull grey nothing. Usually it happens because you hunted for the exact colour of a cheek too early. You had not yet decided where the light was and where the shadow was. With no structure underneath, every stroke argues with the last one. The argument averages out to sludge.
Chalk is the tidier failure. It happens when you lighten skin with white, and only white. White does not just make paint lighter. It cools it, and it kills it. Real skin in the light stays warm. Lift it with white alone and you get that powdery, embalmed look. No amount of blending will save it.
Fix the light before you touch colour: the classical model

Before I mix a single skin tone, I sort out the light. I use the classical model of light, the one every form obeys in any medium. There is the highlight, where the form faces the source most directly. Around it sits the light plane. The halftones come as the surface begins to turn. Along the terminator runs the core shadow, where the form turns away. And last comes the reflected light, bouncing back up into that shadow. Get those reading in order and a head sits solidly in space. Skip them and no colour will save it.
So squint. Group everything into two families, light and shadow. Lay the shadow in as one connected, slightly transparent mass. Keep the terminator honest. If that map reads right with your eyes half shut, you have solved most of the problem already. And you have not touched colour yet.
Mix skin in zones, but read the person in front of you

There is no single flesh tone. The moment you stop looking for one, everything gets easier. A face reads as living because its colour travels across broad zones. But how those zones behave depends on who is sitting for you. The classic pattern runs cool and yellow across the forehead. It goes warm and red through the cheeks and nose. Then it cools again down the jaw. This sitter breaks that last part. He is a farmer with a deep, weathered suntan. His skin is reddish, almost Native American. So there is no cool grey green in his chin at all. His lower face stays warm and full of red, right down into the neck. A pale British sitter would have cooled off toward the jaw.
So for the lights on the forehead I reach for naples yellow and a little indian yellow with white. The cheeks, nose and ears are the warm engine of the face. That is where the red lives, so I bring in light red and naphthol red. On this man the red carries all the way down. My darks are vandyke brown. On its own it is fairly neutral and leans a little cool. So the trick is knowing which way to tip it. Light red pushes it warm. A touch of ultramarine light or ivory black pulls it cool. That is the real skill. You are not hunting for a colour. You are deciding which way to nudge a neutral.
His skin is so reddish that the whole portrait settles into a warm, red key. A paler European sitter would never sit there. Mix those notes separately and the flat mud starts to look like it has blood under it.
Temperature is the thing that actually sells it

If you take one idea from all of this, take this one. Warm and cool sit opposite each other across the light and the shadow. Warm light, cool shadows. Or the reverse. But never both warm or both cool. Keep the shadows thin and transparent so they fall back. Keep the lights thicker and more opaque so they come forward. That quiet back and forth of temperature does more than any single colour to make skin look like skin. It also cures both problems at once. Mud is temperature collapsing into grey. Chalk is temperature gone cold. Hold the warm and the cool apart, and neither one can take hold.
How I mix skin tones, on the palette and on the canvas
Here is the part that took me longest to trust. I get the note roughly right on the palette. But a good share of the real mixing happens on the canvas itself. I put a warm light down next to a cooler halftone. Then I let them meet and half blend where they sit. I do not stir them into one perfect colour first. Mixing everything to completion on the palette is exactly how you flatten skin into mud. Leaving some of it to happen on the canvas is how it stays alive.
My palette

Fewer colours means fewer chances to muddle them. This is the palette I actually use for these portraits. It mixes every skin tone I need and stays in tune with itself.
- Titanium white
- Indian yellow
- Naples yellow deep extra
- Vandyke brown
- Light red
- Naphthol red
- Ultramarine light
- Ivory black
There is no tube of flesh colour in there, and there does not need to be. Ivory black with one of the yellows gives the muted greens for the halftones.
My greys start about as simply as it gets. Ivory black and titanium white always mixes to a cool grey. From there I steer it. To warm it I add a very little vandyke brown or light red, or an earth like burnt umber or yellow ochre. Always tiny amounts. To take it colder I add a dab of ultramarine light, or the blue with a touch of red mixed to a quiet purple. Vandyke brown works the same way on its own. It is a near neutral dark that light red warms and the blue or black cools. If your skin keeps going muddy, try working a whole head from this handful. See how much cleaner it stays.
When it is already mud
Say you are reading this with a muddy face already staring back at you. Do not scrub. Scrubbing is how it got muddy. Take a palette knife and lift the worst passage off. You do not need a clean canvas, just less sludge to fight. Re-state the shadow as one transparent shape and leave it alone. Then set a clean, warm light note next to a cooler halftone. Let them meet on the canvas. Do not drag the brush back and forth between them. And then, the hard part, put the brush down before you fix it back into mud. Knowing when to stop is half of alla prima.
See it in the paint
If you would rather watch it happen, here is my portrait tutorial. I take a head through the classical model of light, and into mixing and placing these skin tones on the canvas.
A few questions I get
Why do my skin tones look muddy when the colours looked right on the palette?
Because value and temperature matter more than the mixture in the well. Skip the light and shadow structure, or stir warm into cool, and a reasonable looking colour still lands as mud.
How do I stop skin going chalky?
Lighten with warmth, not just white. A little naples yellow, indian yellow or red in your light mixtures keeps them warm and alive. Otherwise they go pale and cold.
What palette is best for avoiding muddy skin?
A limited one. Mine is titanium white, indian yellow, naples yellow deep extra, vandyke brown, light red, naphthol red, ultramarine light and ivory black. Fewer pigments mean cleaner, more controllable mixtures.
Can a beginner really paint skin alla prima?
Yes, and it is arguably the best way to learn. Painting wet into wet in a single sitting shows you cause and effect straight away. That is how you train your eye to catch mud and chalk before they set.